Sunday, February 24, 2008

Indian Directors- A Report Card.



On March 30th, 1955, Truffaut published in Art a tract entitled “The French Cinema short on Ambition,” wherein he suggested precise rating of the “89 French Directors of the day, whom he divided into five categories. I had just finished watching most, if not all, works of past and contemporary directors of Indian Cinema. This works range from the Avant Grade films of John Abrahm to Farah Khan pastiche 70s curry antidote, Om Shanti Om.

I, confess, I must have missed few noted Directors and a number of them from Telegu and Tamil Cinema- Since I’m yet to get familiar with a lot of film from South.. Yet, from whatever I have seen till date, which includes more than 500 Indian Films ranging across language and Directors from experimental to commercial. I decided to lay down the “Directors “according to the five broad categories laid by Truffaut.

The basic rule of thumb used to categorize this “Directors” was by looking at their body of work, their theme, constituency, personal stamp, mise-en-scene, honesty and Star Power. At the same time ,it was important to understand under what social and economic condition was the film made, this fact really helps in dividing an important line between truth and deceit.

Another important element in my classification was to understand whether this film represent or show anything about the era or milieu they were made. Can I relate it to anything I have seen in life or read in fiction? Does it belong complete to Cinema and if it does, What is the power of image? And how did the Director achieve it. Every film and its inherent theme could have a counterpart in World Cinema. So, I also looked ,and compared two films to understand where a Director lacks or shows a distinction from where the material could be copied or was it influenced. It also allowed me to put two pictures of the same theme and weigh it accordingly.

I was also interested in knowing and understanding under what economic condition and freedom did the “Director make this film” , was he backed by a studio to deliver the film or the money came from various Productions, each and every thing counts in determining who fits where.

I know their aren’t any hard and fast rules for finding objectivity as such, but all opinions are purely based on looking at the body of work from various angles as mentioned above. And I tried to bring out an accurate portrait where things stand today.

I suggest to all people who read the blog or post to send a feedback and suggestion so that we can really improve and create a certain discourse over the works and standing of “Directors” in Indian Cinema.

I have included few films along with the Directors name, due to my in -ability to understand HTML(As the blogger keeps giving an error) there will be a slight mis-match between the Director column and Films.

Auteur

Directors

Films

John Abrahm


Adoor Gopalakrishnan


Govindan Aravindan-


Satyajit Ray


Girish Kasaravalli

Ritwik Ghatak

Buddadeb Dasgupta

Mirnal Sen

Guru Dutt

Jahnu Barua

Kumar Shahani

Bimal Roy

Mani Kaul

Shyam Benegal

Agraharathil Kazhuthai, Cheriachante Krurakrithyangal.


Anatharam, Swaryamvaram.


Chidambaram, Kanchana Seetha, Pokkuveyil


The Apu Triology, Satranj ke Khiladi


Ghatashraddha, Thaayi Saheba, Dweepa

Megha Daka Tara, Ajantrik, Subarnarekha

Uttara, Kaalpurrsh

Khandhar, Bhuvan Shome, Ek Din Achanak

Pyaasa, Kagez Ke Phool.

Xagoroloi Bohu Door, Halodhia Choraye Baodhan Khai

Kasbha, Maya Darpan, Char Adhyay

Do Bigha Zameen, Madhumita, Bandini, Devdas

Uski Roti, Drupad, Idiot.

Nishant, Manthan, Bhumika, Ankur.


The Representatives of Quality

Directors

Films

Rituporno Ghosh

Aparna Sen

Mani Ratnam

Prakash Jha

Vishal Bhardwaj

Anurag Kashyp

Sudhir Mishra

Raj Kapoor

Hrisikeh Mukherjee

Girish Karnad

Ram Gopal Verma

Chetan Anand

Basu Chaterjee

Nagesh Kukunoor

V Shantaram

Mehbooh Khan

Raj Khosla

Gautom Ghosh

Unishe April, Rain Coat, Choker Bali

36 Chowringee Lane, Mr& Mrs Iyer, 15 Park Avenue

Nayakan, Bombay, Dil Se

Gangajal, Aparhan.

Omkara, Maqbool

Black Friday, Paanch

Hazaaron Khwaishein Ais, Khoya, Khoya Chand.

Awaara, Mis 420, Mera Naam Joker, Aag

Golmaal, Chhoti Si Baat and Naram Garam.

VamshaVruksha, "Tabbaliyu neenade magane"

Satya, Company, Sarkar, Bhoot

Neccha Nagar, Haqeeqat

Dillagi, Chitchor, Choti Si Baat, Khatta Meetha

Dor, Iqbal.

Do Aankhein Barah Haath, Dr. Kotnis ki Amar Kahani

Aan, Mother India, Andaz

C ID, Who Kyun Thi?

Paar,Dakhal,Yatra.



Honest Commerical Film Directors

Director

Films

Farah Khan

Manmohan Desai

Rajkumar Hirani

Rakeysh Om Mehra

Madur Bandarkar

Mahesh Bhatt

Ramesh Sippy

Prakash Mehra

Yash Chopra

Priyadarshan

Farhan Akhtar

J P Dutta

Sooraj Barjatiya

Vijay Anand

Rakesh Roshan

S. Shankar

Manoj Kumar

Pradep Sarkar


Ashoutoush Gowarikar

Main Hoon Na, Om Shanti Om

Amar Akbar Anthony, Mard, Coolie

Munnabhai series

Rang De Basanti

Traffic Signal, Chandini Bar, Page 3

Arth, Janam, Naam

Sholay, Shakit, Buniyaad

Zanjeer, Lawarris

Waqt, Lamhe, Deewar

Hera-Pheri, Kaalapaani

Dil Chaatha Hai, Don, Lakshya

Border

Maine Pyar Kiya, Hum Apke Hain Kaun

Gudie, Jhonny Mera Naam, Teesri Manzil

Krrish, Koyla, Koi Mil Gaya

Shivaji, Nayak

Roti Kapda Aur Makan, Kranti

Parineeta


Laagan, Swades, Jodha Akbar



Dishonest Film Directors.

Directors

Films


Subhash Ghai


Vidhu Vinod Chopra


Sanjay Leela Bhansali

Karan Johar



Yaadein, Kisna, Taal, Pardes, Karz.

Misson Kashmir,Eklavya,.

Devdas, Black, Sawarriya

KANK, KBKG.


Semi- Ambitious Directors

Kunal Kholi

Pooja Bhaat

Virkam Bhaat

Mohit Suri

Sanjay Gupta

Nikhil Advani

Sidharth Anand

Shrish Kunder

Kabir Khan

Tanuja Chandra

Aditya Chopra

Anil Sharma

Anand Kumar

5 comments:

Shubhank said...

Work on the alignment man. Screw the HTML, just the 'name - movies' thingy works quite well.

BTW whare is 'Sai Paranjpe' (Chashme Baddoor, Katha, Sparsh)?
You forgot Mira Nair as well.

I did not get the list of Dishonest directors. Why? I understand that Bhansali does label his movies as art-house and they turn out to be nothing more than run-of-the-mill masala shit but Karan Johar? Although I have a hatred for that man but he has always claimed to be a commercial director.

nitesh said...

Man tried all shit, but the fuck yeah I couldn't get it right- there is an HTML error as I try publishing.

Yep, Sai Pranjpe... I knew some would point it out. I knew I'm missing few people...Thanks Again.

Mira Nair, Shekhar Kapur, and Deepha Mehta I haven't included because of their body of work not entirely being made here, so it was difficult to categorize them under the same banner. Even though they are Indian filmmaker, I found it difficult on my part categorizes them.

I was really confused about Karan Johar. But what really put me in this category was his new commitment to tell serious or mature stories whether as Producer in Kal ho Na Ho, or as a Director in KANK, tackling issues which he believed are important and profound, but his in-ability to really mould them into a good film putt’s him in this bracket. As it was again nothing more than the same commercial work.

For people like Subash Ghai it was the loss of individuality from Pardes onwards. And same goes for Vidhu Vinod Chopra a talented filmmaker, snobbish about his cinematic up bringing and tradition but after Parindea all his works lost the honest, integrity that he so blunty stood for.

Aayush "Gravito" Shrut said...

What we need is one good director :(,but the list is very very good....hats off to you for making this one

CN said...

I totally agree with the list of "dishonest directors".

Anonymous said...

Cool.
ps- Is aamir khan too 'mainstream' to feature in the purple/green list? :)

-jj